The November Greater Atlanta Coin Show visitors enjoyed a nice but overcast day outside
and a busy bourse inside filled with dealers and their displays of numismatics and
We appreciate all the people that helped make the coin show a busy place to be - from our
visitors to our dealers to our security and to the hotel's staff. Thank you one and all for your
contributions to the show.
As an aside, we offer commiseration to the hotel's crew. The hotel hosted a wedding party
in the ballroom the evening before that did not end until 4:30 in the morning.
The crew had to breakdown the room, clean it and perform the set-up for our event in just a
handful of hours. And, kudos to them, they did a great job.
As is usual, the hotel also hosted a couple of churches on Sunday. We welcomed several
of the church-goers who stopped by the show.
Just briefly, let's touch on a big non-numismatic, non-collectible topic heard frequently on
That's the election, of course.
If your candidate won, lost or didn't even place (no electoral
votes), the result certainly means the actions in the nation's
capital will be different over the next four years.
Regardless, the new president will do some things we like,
some we don't and even some that are just strange and need
clarification. Just like all the previous presidents.
Now, for a few items on the bourse...
This month, let's take a look at some errors, some
unintentional and one definitely on purpose.
© Copyright Atlanta Coin Expositions, 2008-2017. All Rights Reserved.
Several of the links on the pages within this web site go to affiliate vendors.
A vendor affiliation can mean a small monetary compensation to the web site owner at no additional cost to you.
Greater Atlanta Coin Show
2017, our 30th year of monthly coin shows
Coin Show - Monthly Notes from November 2016
The first coin is a 2009 Native American dollar coin.
In 2009, the coin previously known as the Sacagawea dollar
became the Native American dollar to memorialize the
heritage of the Indian nations. Each year, a new reverse
design highlights an important legacy.
The first design emphasized their agricultural knowledge
with the Three Sisters design.
The Three Sisters referred to the benefits of planting
squash, beans and corn together.
The bean plant pulls nitrogen from the air, the corn plant provides support for the bean vine and the squash plant
provides shade to hold moisture for the plants' roots.
The term "three sisters" for that type of farming is attributed to the Iroquois, however several different tribal nations
used the method of planting corn, beans and squash together.
The legislation introducing the Native American coinage also specified that the date, mint mark and "E Pluribus Unum"
be incused on the edge of the coin rather than on the obverse or reverse.
That specification leads us to the first error.
The obverse and reverse of this dollar coin looks like any of its
However, this 2009 Three Sisters Native American dollar coin
does not have any edge lettering.
The PCGS holder uses three "fingers" to hold the coin and to
allow the smooth edge to show without its inscriptions.
The US Mint produced just over 77 million of the Three Sisters
Native American dollar coins including the Philadelphia and
Denver circulating coins and the San Francisco proof coins.
Per PCGS, the population of the MS-65 Missing Edge
Lettering is 1,383 and the total population including those of
MS-63 through MS-68 shows currently at 4,624.
Doing a little math, that puts the total population of Missing
Edge Lettering 2009 Native American Dollar at 0.006% of all
the minted Three Sisters coins.
That's a small number.
Next on our error list is another mint error, however this time it's
not a coin. Rather it is the certificate.
Oddly, the error certificates included the correct metal content
and weights for the five silver quarters, but it was the Roosevelt
dime and Kennedy half dollar coins with the wrong information.
The metal content and the weight for each coin reflected that of
the clad coins.
Of course, some people value error coins. Currently on
eBay, several similar error coins graded by NGC as MS-65
range from $43 to $129. (The $43 is a bid number in one
eBay shop while the $129 is a fixed number in a different
The true value is what an error collector is willing to pay.
Back in 2003, the US Mint produced red pack silver proof sets with
red printed certificates of authenticity.
But, probably due to some hasty copy/paste from the file for the
clad proof set certificate to the file for the silver proof set certificate,
a couple of errors occurred.
Someone caught the error during the distribution process. The US Mint mailed a letter of explanation and apology with
corrected certificates enclosed to those who had already received their silver proof sets.
However, the incorrect certificates of authenticity can still be found in 2003 silver proof sets.
Unlike an error coin, generally an error certificate does not add or subtract value from the associated coins, but for
some collectors it does pique their interest.
Last on our list for this month is an intentional error coin.
So, what is an intentional error?
It's someone's intention to defraud and profit illegally, otherwise known as a fake.
This particular fake coin is a 2010 Silver American Eagle dollar coin.
Looking at the packaging, whoever produced the fake coin made sure the packaging included legitimate US Mint
The box, clam shell, certificate of authenticity and clear holder are official US Mint Silver American Eagle components.
The real components help trick the unsuspecting buyer.
In the picture, the left side reflects a "real" US Mint 2010 Silver American Eagle with the right side showing the fake
coin. They appear to be the same US Mint product don't they?
Looking at the coins side-by-side, both obverse and reverse, the difference becomes more obvious.
On the other hand, someone in a hurry, and not
looking at the coins side-by-side, could
potentially fall for the fake coins.
Oddly, when holding the two coins in your
hands, the real coin in one hand and the fake in
the other, the fake coin feels lighter.
In reality, it's 1.1 grams heavier. (Both coins
weighed separately in their plastic holders.)
In another observation, the fake coin moves
slightly in its holder, shake and it rattles,
whereas the real US Mint coin fits perfectly
within its plastic holder.
Look closely at the comparison pictures to see
the precision of the US Mint's artists and
process on the left and the lesser quality of the
fake on the right.
Again, the imposter is good, but with education and attention
to the details, the fake can be spotted without a real coin for
If you are in the market for a Silver American Eagle coin, or
any coin for that matter, make sure you gain knowledge about
the coin and purchase from trusted sources.
That's it for the examples for this month.
Mark your calendars for the next Greater Atlanta Coin Show on December 11, 2016.
The December show will be in the hotel's Hamilton's Restaurant. It is just down the hallway from the ballroom space,
between the elevators and the front lobby.
The restaurant looks out over the golf course and has a view of Kennesaw mountain in the distance.
The dealers of the Greater Atlanta Coin Show will pack the restaurant area with their displays of coins, bullion, currency,
other money-related collectibles and some non-numismatic collectibles, too.