What a day for the May 2016 Greater Atlanta Coin Show, temperatures in the low 70s with
sunshine and clouds. Just a beautiful spring day to be out and about.
And, that's what many people did with lots of them visiting the coin show's bourse to see what
the dealers had on display.
As always, we appreciate the many people who visit the coin show, the dealers that fill the
bourse, our security and the hotel's staff that supports the show.
Many dealers filled the tables positioned around the ballroom with their showcases full of a
variety of collectibles.
Let's take a look at a few of the beauties on display starting with a couple of 1883 CC Morgan
In 1883, the US Mint produced over 28 million of the Morgan dollars at their Philadelphia, New
Orleans, San Francisco and Carson City facilities. Of the minted coins, Carson City produced
less than five percent or just over 1.2 million coins.
NGC (Numismatic Guaranty Corporation) graded these two examples
with one as MS-65 DPL and the other as MS-65+ PL.
The ANA Grading Standards describes the MS-65 (Mint State 65) for
the Morgan Dollar as:
No trace of wear; nearly as perfect as the MS-67 except for a few
additional minute bagmarks or surface mars. Has full mint luster but
may be unevenly toned. Any unusual striking traits must be described.
One of the coins shows MS-65+, which makes it better than an MS-65
but not quite good enough for the next higher grade.
NGS also noted DPL and PL on the coins.
© Copyright Atlanta Coin Expositions, 2008-2017. All Rights Reserved.
Several of the links on the pages within this web site go to affiliate vendors.
A vendor affiliation can mean a small monetary compensation to the web site owner at no additional cost to you.
Greater Atlanta Coin Show
2017, our 30th year of monthly coin shows
Coin Show - Monthly Notes from May 2016
DPL is an abbreviation for Deep Proof Like defined by the ANA as an uncirculated coin with a high degree of proof like
surface, more than a PL (Proof Like) but less than a DMPL (Deep Mirror Proof Like) coin.
Side note, in that year, the Mint produced just over 1000 true proof coins at their Philadelphia location.
So, which is better? An MS-65+ Proof Like or an MS-65 Deep Proof Like?
Well, that's really in the eyes of the beholder...both are beautiful Liberty ladies...
Next on our tour of the bourse is a PCGS (Professional Coin
Grading Service) 1892 Liberty Head or Barber Half Dollar
Coin from the Philadelphia Mint.
In that year, the US Mint produced just under 2.4 million of the
half dollar coins at their Philadelphia, New Orleans and San
The Philadelphia Mint struck almost 40% of the coins
including 1245 proof versions with the remaining quantity for
PCGS graded this 1892 Barber half dollar coin as a
In general, the ANA's Grading Standards describes the Proof
62 coins as:
An impaired or dull character may be evident in the Proof
fields as well as on the higher areas. Clusters of small marks
may be present throughout, with a few large marks or nicks in
prime focal areas. Hairlines will be heavy and very noticeable.
Large, unattractive scuff marks might be seen on major
features. Overall eye appeal is barely acceptable for coins
struck in precious metals. Copper coins will show a
diminished color and tone and may be sub-par in appearance
Contact Marks: May have distracting marks in prime focal
areas and/or secondary areas.
Hairlines: Fairly extensive overall.
Fields: May be original or impaired, with mirror surface dull or
Eye Appeal: Varies widely for silver and gold, generally low
for copper and nickel issues.
The ANA's Grading Standard provides this general description for the
Proof 66 grade:
Has above average quality of strike and full mirror (or other style Proof)
surface, with no more than two or three minor but noticeable contact
marks. A few light hairlines may show under magnification, or there may
be one or two light scuff marks showing on frosted surfaces or in the
field. The eye appeal is above average and very pleasing for the variety.
If copper, the coin has attractive color (mint red or blended to brown),
with only a few flyspecks and one or two tiny spots at most/
Contact Marks: Several small; a few may be in prime focal areas.
Hairlines: None visible without magnification.
Fields: Above average. Fully original.
Eye Appeal: Above average.
Let's begin with the oldest five-cent first, an 1881 Shield nickel.
The US Mint produced less than 75,000 of the 1881Shield nickels and
only at one location, Philadelphia. Of those, the Mint made just over
3500 proof versions.
NGC graded this 1881 nickel with its beautifully detailed shield on a
PCGS also noted this coin as CAM in its grading.
Per the ANA, CAM is an abbreviation of cameo contrast, which, on a Proof coin, denotes the contrast between a
mirrorlike field and the frosted or satiny (cameo) portrait or devices.
In other words, this coin is not a "perfect" proof, but at 124 years old and of a small population (1245), it is still a
very nice coin.
The next three coins on our bourse tour are all of the five-cent denomination, and all were graded PR 66.
The next five-cent coin on our list is a Liberty Head or V
nickel designed by Charles Barber.
When first introduced in 1883, the coin enabled the
ne'er-do-wells to use the nickel to make a counterfeit
five-dollar gold coin.
Since the initial versions lacked a reference to
denomination on the coin, only the Roman numeral "V"
for five, the counterfeiters quickly coated the coins with
gold and passed them as five dollars.
Soon, the word "CENTS" was added to deter the
This example, however, came from 1906 long after the
thieves were thwarted.
In this year, the US Mint's Philadelphia location
produced less than 39 million of the Liberty Head or V
nickels with only 1725 proof versions.
Liberty certainly shines on this 110-year old coin
graded by NGC.
Our last nickel is an Indian Head or Buffalo Nickel from
The US Mint produced just over 30 million of the coins
at their Philadelphia, Denver and San Francisco
At Philadelphia, they struck 1050 proof versions of the
This PCGS graded coin also has the green CAC
sticker, which means the coin's grade was
independently verified by the Certified Acceptance
Interestingly, on the CAC web site entering the coin's
serial number from the certified holder yields more
For this example, CAC notes it is a 1915 Nickel
Buffalo Type 2 Matte PR66 providing more insight into
That completes our bourse tour for the May Greater Atlanta Coin Show.
These coins represent a small, very small, sample of the numismatic items found on the bourse.
Mark your calendars for the next monthly coin show on Sunday, June 12, 2016, and come see the dealers' displays
and offerings of coins, currency, bullion and other collectibles in their showcases.
The ANA's Grading Standards defines the Matte
A special type of Proof finish used at the
Philadelphia Mint prior to America's entrance into
World War I.
This method was first employed by the Paris Mint
and was later adopted for a limited time during the
years 1908 through 1916 for certain (but not all)
issues by the Philadelphia Mint.
The surface is prepared by a special die-etching or
pickling process that gives a grainy appearance to
the coins struck from such dies.
At 101 years old, this Buffalo nickel is a beautiful
example of the US Mint's production methods of the
early 20th century.